Why work-life balance is a myth and what can be more beneficial

Working parents and moms especially have been sold this idea of "work-life balance" as the answer to juggling overwhelming demands at work and never-ending demands at home. It has mostly been a way to make systemic structural failures feel like, yet again, an individual personal problem requiring individual solutions. As though the caregiver whose workday ends at 5 pm, but whose child needs to be picked up from school by 3 pm and has gymnastics at 4:30 pm or football at 5:30 pm, can solve this issue with a better color-coded calendar. Or as though having no energy left for the "second shift" in the evenings of making dinner, doing homework, and running to evening sports practices or dance lessons can be solved by 30-minute one-pan/one-pot dinner recipes or meal prepping on Sundays.

While having individual systems in place may help some days flow more smoothly, it doesn't add more hours or resources to the day for outdated work models, or address the reality that many workplaces still don't recognize employees' identities and responsibilities as caregivers. Roughly 1 in 4 American adults acts as a family caregiver, and younger generations are affected even more: 74% of Millennials and 67% of Gen Z identify as current or future caregivers, per the Employee Benefits Research Institute.

An idea that may be more achievable, and more acknowledging of current work system failures, is work-life integration. While work-life balance implies a "finish line" of sorts, it also treats work and life as opposites. Finding harmony when transitioning between roles may be more achievable than trying to give equal amounts of time and energy to various roles and tasks.

To gain more insight into how work-life integration can be more beneficial than work-life balance, I spoke with mother, writer and PhD researcher Kiya Taylor, based in Sydney, Australia. Kiya writes about motherhood and the work mothers do, paid and unpaid, on Substack in her series Promoted to Mother.

I asked Kiya, "Do you think the pursuit of work-life balance has unintentionally become another standard that mothers feel they have to achieve? If so, what does a healthier alternative look like?"

She shared, "Yes, absolutely. When we use concepts like balance, it pushes the problem and solution back onto the individual - but the problem is rarely that mothers are failing at 'balance' - the problem is that many of us are being forced to exist in two worlds that were not designed to be integrated. Workplaces were not designed (and rarely updated) to integrate the work of mothering, and the work of mothering - especially in a modern, globalised world - was not set up to integrate a rigid workplace. Rather than seeing a mother's tension in doing both as a system or structural issue, we're told it's our own behaviour at best, or lack of discipline at worst, that's both responsible for causing it and for fixing it, too.

Researchers often explain this tension through two competing social ideas - mothers are often simultaneously held to the 'ideal worker' norm (i.e., that the ideal worker is someone completely devoted to work without care obligations) and the 'good' or 'intensive' mother idea - that mothers should put mothering above all else. It's a tension that often leaves mothers feeling they have to abandon or completely outsource one or the other to 'succeed'.

If you really examine it, nowhere in these two social ideas is there even space for them to be balanced, as each, in many ways, cancels out the other. You can't balance two roles that society has deemed to be all-encompassing unto themselves."

When asked what a healthier approach could look like, Kiya shared:

"So what can be done? Well, this is where ideas like work-life integration are offered up as a healthier way to look at the tensions. Personally, I think this can be a great approach - so long as we're not trying to dress up the concept of balance in a more aggressive way. We can't just think, 'Damn, I can't balance these two jigsaw puzzles! Instead I'm going to smash them together until they join!'

A healthy integration, to me, is looking at both all-encompassing roles, and prioritising and assessing what parts of each role you want to keep, and what parts you want to let go of in order to make space for them to 'join up well'.

But the hard truth here is that even in a healthier, more empowered 'integration' - we're still asking women to make individual compromises for systemic issues. We're asking women to go part-time or freelance or outsource parenting to external providers - as opposed to asking workplaces to change, or community structures of mothering support to be better established."

Kiya has a unique perspective as both a researcher studying mothers going back to work and a 30-something mother to a toddler. We discussed the biggest lessons she has learned in both roles. Kiya said, "Honestly, I regularly struggle with how closely aligned my work and life are. It's hard to decenter your own, very 'living' experience of mothering and work, while also studying it. I would say, though, that one thing I've found very reassuring is being able to find the names for things that can otherwise be left as these murky feelings you think you're almost being gaslit in. For example, the two social norms I mentioned above - 'the ideal worker' or the 'good mother' - knowing these are real, documented and studied concepts is really helpful in making sense of my own lived experience of feeling like I was no longer 'valuable' in the workplace as a mother.

There have been many big lessons around surrender and control and presence - the work of mothering and motherhood itself provides endless opportunities for growth."

Since work-life balance is an idea often sold without addressing why there is a need for it in the first place, I asked Kiya, "If you could recommend one change every employer should make, what would it be?" She shared, "If we assume every employer has paid maternity leave for six months (which I know is a recommendation in itself) and that there are supportive policies on breastfeeding - I think there's a lot to be said about implementing certain flexibility which is company-wide, not an individual opt-in or just for parents/carers.

When you make it the latter, it can inadvertently reinforce flexibility stigma, which can penalise those who take it. To create a workplace culture that is open to everyone having a greater 'work/life' integration (which is generally better for productivity) - and therefore no one being stigmatised or penalised for it - your policies and culture need to focus on shifting flexibility for everyone. And just a reminder - flexibility comes in various forms, not just hours or location!" (Kiya referenced an article by Ludmila N. Praslova, which outlines other types of flexibility: schedule, place, mode, continuity and workload.)

Many working mothers and caregivers talk about the tension and pull of carrying multiple identities, such as mother and employee. I asked Kiya what she has learned about navigating these competing roles. She shared, "Funnily enough, I think it's in our identities that the integration of 'work/life' is more healthily achievable than often in the practicality of integrating our work/life in the doing of each day. Accepting that we're beautifully varied creatures that contain multitudes means that there is more than enough room for us to be mother and X and X and X and X.

But when it comes to the actual navigation of the roles - my personal experience is a work in progress. I do my best to try and define boundaries of when I'm switching into roles, but that only works when you have the scaffolding to support that - i.e., working when you have childcare, or when they're napping - it's very hard to do both at the same time, especially once they start moving around!"

The most important takeaway from my conversation with Kiya is that work-life integration shouldn't become another individual solution to a structural problem. There is value in the language we use to recognize that our identities, responsibilities and lives will inevitably overlap. But mothers and caregivers shouldn't have to endlessly rearrange themselves to make incompatible systems work. If we want work and life to actually integrate, the responsibility can't sit entirely with the people trying to navigate both. Employers, communities and the structures surrounding families have a role in making that integration possible, too.

WIDD

We provide access to resources, and a supportive community for Women innovators in Digital and Design through networking events, inspiring interviews, 1:1 mentorship, online courses, and the showcasing of talents for career opportunities. We come from many countries and backgrounds, yet we are united by common goals.

https://www.widdnetwork.com/
Next
Next

Prada's Drawing Prada campaign makes human creativity part of the story, but is that enough?